Books / Learning comic
The Question Nobody Put on the Form
Theme: Critical Thinking & Data Literacy
Nadiya is ready to announce a new pool programme after sixty-four of eighty returned forms say yes. Then June explains that she wanted earlier opening, not the paid class bundled into the same question. Luis, who visits after work, has never seen the morning-only form. With volunteer analyst Tom, Nadiya pauses the announcement and investigates what the answers actually mean. The team separates proposals, tests ambiguous wording, makes room for disagreement and widens its invitation without pretending a bigger pile proves representativeness. A clearer report keeps unanswered questions and practical constraints visible. This original community story turns survey design into a human problem: understanding people is different from collecting the answer you hoped to hear, and a useful decision can still leave room for disagreement.
Start reading →View in the interactive libraryAbout this book
At the community swimming pool, programme coordinator Nadiya has a result she can fit on a poster: sixty-four yes answers from eighty returned forms. She imagines an enthusiastic announcement. Volunteer analyst Tom checks the arithmetic, but regular swimmer June asks a more awkward question. What exactly did the form ask people to support? June wanted an earlier opening time, not the optional paid class bundled into the same checkbox. Her answer cannot honestly be divided into two preferences after the fact. Then Luis arrives after work. He uses the pool regularly but never encountered forms offered only during morning sessions. His absence from the pile does not reveal what every evening visitor thinks. It does reveal a gap between the people Nadiya hopes to describe and the people her collection method reached. The team pauses the announcement without throwing away the original responses. They preserve the wording and method, and begin by clarifying which decisions actually need information. Their revised draft separates the opening proposal from the paid class and explains what would happen to existing sessions. A small pilot exposes another problem: June imagines six when she reads early, while Luis imagines seven-thirty. Tom asks them to explain the question before supplying an interpretation. This exercise tests understanding, not public support. Specific proposed hours replace an elastic adjective. The group also discovers answer choices that allow praise but nowhere for disagreement, uncertainty or an unsuitable time to go. Nadiya removes a promotional appeal from the factual introduction. Caring about the pool should not require endorsing this particular plan. Invitations become available in the evening and through additional community channels, while the team records how participation was sought. A wider invitation is an improvement, not proof of a random sample or complete coverage. When the second collection grows larger, Tom resists treating its size as evidence that every remaining limitation has disappeared. The returned forms raise quieter questions too. A blank item is not automatically opposition. Different questions may have different denominators. Employer names and medical histories are unnecessary for recording whether a proposed timetable works, so the team removes intrusive fields rather than making participants justify their circumstances. Changed wording and recruitment also mean that a different percentage cannot simply be announced as a change in public opinion. The two rounds must retain their separate contexts. The final report offers distinctions instead of a victorious headline. Opening preferences and class preferences stay separate; respondents are not renamed the whole community. Staffing, costs and permission to change a rota require their own checks. After those checks, the fictional manager authorises a limited early-opening trial with a review date, not an automatic permanent change. June still dislikes the class proposal. Her disagreement is evidence that the process can hear something inconvenient. The story closes with a better question before the next form is printed: who has not even had a chance to see it? Understanding an answer requires care about its meaning, its missing voices and the claim built upon it.